The Star of Bethlehem

Above Us Only Sky.....

  • Homepage
  • Astronomy & Science
  • Current Affairs
  • Life in General
  • Sceptical Comment
  • Local Comment
  • About

Dec 27: The Star of Bethlehem

Clear thinking
Every year I notice normally sane scientists - astronomers whose work I otherwise admire - throw away the science with their attempts to justify the so-called Star of Bethlehem.

Despite the lack of any contemporary corroborating evidence for this astounding phenomena, they start - unscientifically - with a preconception that the Bible story is true.

Then they usually attribute the "star" to a comet, planetary conjunction or supernova, because they know that it could not possibly be a normal star.

Think about it:

The bible says it was a star. S_T_A_R, star. Calling it anything other than a star is calling the Bible - God's word - as W_R_O_N_G, wrong. So why not save a step and just accept that the whole story is a fit up? 

If it was a star that came so close to hang over a barn, you would not only see it coming for months but everybody and everything else would be fried to a crisp. If it was a star, there would have been no night!

The people of ancient times were familiar with comets and they were familiar with planetary conjunctions (even if they did not understand them). They are not rare and in those days of no light polluted skies, they would have been easily recognised by many people. These events do not just suddenly appear one night, they evolve over several weeks. You see them coming.

Whatever it was - star, supernova, planet or comet - it would rise in the East and set in the West. Follow such an object all night and you will probably end up back at your starting point. 

If it was already setting in the West during the evening, there would be nothing to follow for most of the night and it could not hang over a single barn.

Whatever astronomical object it was, it could not hover over one place, nor could a single building be identified from it. Earth rotates in 24 hours, so the celestial sphere appears to rotate at 15° per hour. A star passing vertically overhead traces a ground velocity of about 400 metres per second. Less than three minutes after passing vertically over Bethlehem, the 'star' would have been  sixty kilometres away, vertically above the Mediterranean Sea.

Just three hours later and it would be overhead in Morocco. 

This would hardly be a marker for one spot on the planet. If the object were truly suspended over Bethlehem, that would imply that the Earth suddenly stopped turning, a truly impossible but immense and catastrophic global event with disastrous tidal waves and other shocking consequences. 

There is no independent historical record to indicate that anything out of the ordinary occurred, either to the Earth or to the celestial sky. All we have are the conflicting Biblical references, which were written decades later, long enough for any truth to be embellished with fantasy. 

The preconceived "evidence" for this fantastic tale is nothing more than a few sentences in a book written by people who had no concept of the science behind their claims. Yet still, grown up adults try to justify it! 

See my more detailed post from 2009 

Posted by roger in Clear thinking

Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry

No Trackbacks

Comments
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

No comments


The author does not allow comments to this entry

Above us only sky...

The glory of the 'heavens' above us are real, their starry splendour is visible to those who look up; but the glory of 'Heaven' is a sad delusion of human minds.
This is the personal blog site of an atheist astronomer.

Wise words

"The important thing is not to stop questioning."
Albert Einstein

Categories

  • XML ABOUT (4)
  • XML ASTRONOMY & SCIENCE
  • XML Astro Forum: MAS (31)
  • XML Astronomers (5)
  • XML Astronomy (56)
  • XML Camera & tripod (41)
  • XML Citizen Science (9)
  • XML Climate Change (13)
  • XML Cosmology (5)
  • XML Dharawal (2)
  • XML Extra-terrestrials (12)
  • XML Lightning (5)
  • XML LX-90 Notes (11)
  • XML Polar Aligning (7)
  • XML Science (2)
  • XML CAMPBELLTOWN
  • XML Bigot watch (12)
  • XML Campbelltown Comment (13)
  • XML CURRENT AFFAIRS
  • XML Australia (33)
  • XML Covid-19 (5)
  • XML Human rights (2)
  • XML International (8)
  • XML Same-Sex Marriage (22)
  • XML LIFE
  • XML Football (13)
  • XML Life at work (6)
  • XML Life in general (25)
  • XML Life in the Sixties (3)
  • XML Life under the knife (4)
  • XML Photography (7)
  • XML What cheeses me off (10)
  • XML SCEPTICAL
  • XML Baloney watch (7)
  • XML Clear thinking (28)
  • XML Decline of Religion (31)
  • XML Ethics (11)
  • XML God delusions (40)
  • XML Vatican watch (26)

All categories

Syndicate This Blog

  • XML RSS 0.91 feed
  • XML RSS 1.0 feed
  • XML RSS 2.0 feed
  • ATOM/XML ATOM 1.0 feed
  • XML RSS 2.0 Comments

Blog Administration

Open login screen
 

Layout by Andreas Viklund | Serendipity template by Carl